I spent about four years convinced brown knee high boots were the boring cousin of black ones. The safe choice. The one your mum would pick. Then I wore a pair to a wedding in Somerset where the “garden” turned out to be a field that hadn’t seen a mower since June, and the black boots I’d almost worn instead would have looked like I was attending a funeral in a bog. The brown pair looked like I’d meant it. That’s the whole pitch, really.
They soften an outfit that black would sharpen into something a bit severe, and there’s a moment where you realise that’s exactly what you wanted.
A good pair earns its keep on the leather. Cheap brown leather goes orange under any decent light, properly grim, like a fake tan gone wrong on a Tuesday. You want something with actual depth to it, a colour that reads more like a conker or strong tea than caramel, because that’s what stops it looking costumey with everything else you own. The shaft matters too. Too tight and you’re doing the ungainly hop to get them off at a friend’s house, too loose and you get that slouchy, saggy look that only works if it’s meant, not if it’s just how the boot fits your calf.
Styling wise, they do more work than people give them credit for. Over jeans tucked in, with a jumper that’s slightly too big, they’re doing your entire fit for you, no more decisions needed. Under a slip skirt in October when it’s not quite cold enough for tights but you’re not brave enough to go bare legged either.
With a camel coat they go almost matchy in the nicest way, like the outfit was dressed by someone who thought about it for longer than four minutes. My colleague Priya took one look at mine with a green dress and said “oh that’s annoyingly good, isn’t it,” which is as close to a compliment as she gets.
They’re built for the bits of the year that are neither one thing nor another. Not full winter, not proper summer. Weddings on farms, long lunches that turn into long walks, the entire month of October basically living in them. Buy the good leather. Skip the orange ones. Learn from my Somerset field so you don’t have to.
Top Picks
